Employee: I would like to discuss my performance and time with the company. Do you have a few minutes?
Boss: Well, no, not really, make it snappy. (Crossing arms, no eye contact)
Employee: (Employee sits down, slumping in chair) I have been with this company for the past several years and all of my evaluations have been excellent but I haven't gotten a raise the last four years.
Boss: (Phone rings, boss answers and starts talking with person on the line for a couple of moments and then hangs up writing something on a paper.) (Seemingly uninterested, fidgeting, tapping pen on desk) So what were you saying?
Employee: (Asking a question more than making a statement) I am asking you to consider giving me a raise.
Boss: Really? (Getting gruff, crossing arms) What makes you think that I have the money to do that?
Employee: (not making eye contact) Well, John has only been here for a year and he just got a raise.
Boss: Yeah, so, (raising voice, pounding fist on desk) it's really none of your business what John makes. Just because he got one doesn't mean anything. (Gets up, moves toward the door)
Employee: So you won't even consider it? (Whining and stomping foot) That's not fair!
Boss: Not unless you have some really convincing reason I should even bother to consider it. (Clears throat) I hate listening to employees like you whine about how unfair things are.
Points for discussion:
• Would you consider this a successful exchange between the boss and employee? Why or why not?
• What went wrong, in your opinion?
• How did the boss make the employee feel?
• What could have been done differently by both parties?

